INTRODUCTION
This report reviews the current state of scientific literature investigating identified
toxic effects after typical use of common household disinfectants (i.e. bleach) and other disinfectants.
Although the CDC stated on May 19th, that COVID-19 infection from surface to hand
contact is unlikely, high level use of chemical disinfectants continues.
As shown in the studies below, the use of household chlorine bleach (and other disifectants) can increase (not decrease) rates of health problems (in both children and adults). All medical studies used in this toxicology report were acquired from the NIH National Library of Medicine database.
This includes the first study below (from the Department of Public Health in Belgium), which found increases in rates of influenza, tonsillitis and ear infection among children living in homes using common household bleach.
IMMUNE SUPPRESSION INDENTIFIED
The surprising finding of chlorine bleach increasing rates of various child infections, is
supported by several studies finding secondary formation of high air levels of
chloroform, carbon-tetrachloride and other toxic chemicals.
Chloroform is a well documented toxic compound and is
unintentionally created when household bleach comes in contact
with organic matter on floors, countertops and other surfaces.
Contact with water was also discussed by scientists as being related to the
rapid increase in toxic chemical formation after bleach applications.
It is important to clarify that these newly formed toxic compounds
occurred after using only bleach, and without bleach being mixed with other disinfectant products.
Chloroform reached unacceptably high air levels within minutes after beginning bleach use in a kitchen setting.
In additional studies listed, chloroform was found to suppress output of the essential
anti-viral immune defense known as interferon (which improves immune function and blocks
virus entry into nearby body cells). These topics are discussed as well.
Other studies of non-bleach disinfectants are reviewed which were found
increase rates neurological birth defects, COPD and asthma.
DOCUMENTATION PROVIDED
All medical studies reviewed below were published in peer reviewed journals currently indexed
in the National Library of Medicine database. Each review provides details on the universities
and research facilities involved - medical journal name - volume -
and link to the original journal article in the National Library of Medicine.
This enables immediate confirmation on the accuracy of information, thereby providing
credibility needed for initiating discussions on this important topic.
In this study out of Barcelona, Spain, researchers studied homes of over 2000 children ages 6-12 in Spain and Finland. Detailed questionnaires were given to the families inquiring about the use of bleach and frequency of infections including influenza, sinusitis, tonsillitis, ear infections, bronchitis and pneumonia. Results showed that using bleach had an opposite effect of what would be expected and actually increased the rate of influenza by 20% - recurring tonsillitis by 35% - and risk of any infection by 18%. The authors concluded by stating:
"Passive exposure to cleaning bleach in the home may have adverse effects on school-age children's health by increasing the risk of respiratory and other infections. The high frequency of use of disinfecting irritant cleaning products may be of public health concern, also when exposure occurs during childhood."
Centre for Environment and Health
Department of Public Health and Primary Care, KU Leuven, Leuven
Belgium Centre for Research in Environmental Epidemiology (CREAL)
Barcelona, Spain CIBER Epidemiología y Salud Pública (CIBERESP)
Barcelona, Spain University Pompeu Fabra (UPF), Barcelona, Spain
Occupational & Environ. Medicine
Vol.73(3):215, 2016
View Journal HERE
Researchers tested 15 cleaning products (including household bleach) for levels of toxic chemicals. Chloroform was detected in all 15 products tested and carbon-tetrachloride in 13 products. Both chemicals have been banned and considered highly toxic. After using the products, the estimated exposure for breathing chloroform gas was .041 mg/kg per day and .0240 for carbon-tetrachloride. The scientists concluded by stating:
"According to the calculated result, the total estimated human exposure of chloroform were determined to exceed the tolerable concentration of inhalation exposure presented by the World Health Organization."
This study adds further support to the hypothesis that chemical disinfectants, rather than helping, could be a significant driving factor in worsening the current state of COVID-19 infections via a weakening of the human immune system. Because of the widespread increase in residential chemical disinfectant use since the COVID-19 outbreak, it is imperative to investigate the immuno-toxicology of chemical disinfectants with special emphasis on children, the elderly and those with weakened chemical detoxification systems (i.e. cytochrome P-450). Non-toxic disinfectants being shown to have similar effectiveness to chemical disinfectants should also be encouraged - including basic detergent, low ph white vinegar and thymol.
Chemosphere
Vol. 174: 157-164, 2017
View Journal HERE
Sodium hypochlorite is the main disinfectant chemical found in household bleach. This study demonstrated that a number of new and highly toxic chemicals are found in indoor air immediately following the use of bleach to disinfect.
Researchers tested 8 different chlorine bleach products for their ability to emit or create
potentially toxic chemicals. Indoor air samples were taken before, during and 30 minutes after bathroom,
kitchen, and floor cleaning applications. Of great concern, the highly toxic chemicals chloroform
and carbon-tetrachloride significantly increased during the use of bleach containing products.
Researchers went on to state:
"One of the most surprising results was the presence of carbon tetrachloride (a probable human carcinogen and powerful greenhouse gas that was banned for household use by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration in very high concentrations (up to 101 mg/m(-3). By mixing surfactants or soap with NaOCl (bleach), it was shown that the formation of carbon tetrachloride and several other halogenated VOCs (15 in total), is possible.
Environ. Science Technology
Vol. 42(5): 1445-51, 2008
View Journal HERE
In this next study from the Dept. of Microbiology and Immunology at University of Louisiana School of Medicine, researchers pretreated mouse embryo cell cultures with a number of different chemicals. Results showed pretreatment with the chemical chloroform severely inhibited the production of alpha/beta interferon by cells.
Since chloroform gas was shown to reach exceptionally high air levels after use of bleach products (as demonstrated in a previous journal review), this study provides a plausible explanation for the higher rates of influenza (and other infections) found in 6-12 year old children living in homes that use bleach products.
Environmental Research
Vol. 31(2):355-361
View Journal HERE
A significant increase in chromosomal aberration (abnormality) frequency was observed in all treatments of NaOCl (sodium hypochlorite).... at 24 and 48 hours compared with the negative control... In conclusion, our data provide evidence that NaOCl (sodium hypochlorite) increases the chromosomal aberration rate, micronuclei formation (small nucleus) and cytotoxicity (cell damage) in human lymphocyte cells in vitro at concentrations approximate 33 times lower than that found in drinking water.
Department of Biology, University of Kafkas, Kars, Turkey
Cytotechnology
Vol. 599:113-119, 2009
View Journal HERE
These results demonstrate that ADBAC+DDAC in combination are teratogenic to rodents. Given the increased use of these disinfectants, further evaluation of their safety in humans and their contribution to health and disease is essential.
Although this study is not related specifically to the CoronaVirus (or other viral infections), it is of concern as this type of disinfectant is being used with much greater frequency during the COVID-19 situation.
Birth Defect Research
Vol. 109(14):1166, 2017
View Journal HERE
As seen in the previous reports, common chemical disinfectants are suspected of weakening the immune system, thereby resulting in higher infection rates for influenza and other pathogens. In this report out of Freiburg University Hospital in Germany, researchers reviewed 4 scientific studies investigating the effectiveness of chemical disinfectants for reducing infection in a hospital setting.
After analyzing results, the study concluded that cleaning of floors with basic detergents was just as effective as using chemical disinfectants.
Scientists concluded by stating:"None of these studies showed lower infection rates associated with routine disinfection of surfaces (mainly floors) versus cleaning with detergent only... Disinfectants may pose a danger to staff, patients, and the environment and require special safety precautions. However, targeted disinfection of certain environmental surfaces is in certain instances an established component of hospital infection control. Given the complex, multifactorial nature of nosocomial (hospital) infections, well-designed studies that systematically investigate the role of surface disinfection are required."
Am J Infectious Control
Vol.32(2):84-9, 2004
View Journal HERE
More to be added soon. Please click the link for additional details.
Canadian Med. Assoc. Jrnl
Vol.190(37):E1097-
View Journal HERE